Old Mill Pottery House Cafe Menu (Update 2025)

Introducing the menu at Old Mill Pottery House Cafe, located in Pigeon Forge, TN, offers a delightful selection of American bakery items. The cafe provides a cozy and charming ambiance, perfect for groups and families, with options for outdoor seating. Customers rave about the hot and delicious dishes such as the Southern burger with bourbon glaze, catfish with popcorn batter, pasta salad, ribeye steak, and homemade honey mustard. The menu also features specialties like fried pecan chicken, tomato and cucumber salad, and the Southern Burger. The waitstaff is described as friendly and efficient, enhancing the overall dining experience. Customers appreciate the use of reusable tableware and the option for gluten-free dishes. With stellar service, generous portion sizes, and an inviting atmosphere, Old Mill Pottery House Cafe comes highly recommended for a relaxed and enjoyable meal.

CHILDREN'S MENU

HAMBURGER

$6.49

CHEESEBURGER

$7.49

OLD MILL CORNDOG

$4.99

GRILLED CHEESE

$4.99

MACARONI & CHEESE

$5.49

COUNTRY HAM EGGS BENEDICT

Thinly sliced country ham topped with poached eggs and hollandaise sauce. Served on toasted English muffin bread. Served with fresh fruit

$12.99

TRULY SOUTHERN BENEDICT

Biscuits topped with fried green tomatoes, country ham, poached eggs, pimiento cheese hollandaise sauce and chopped bacon. Served with fresh fruit

$13.99

EAST TENNESSEE OMELET

Three egg omelet filled with local Swaggertys sausage and Sweet Water Valley Farms cheddar cheese. Served with a fresh buttermilk biscuit

$11.99

STEAK AND EGGS

oz Black Angus sirloin steak with two eggs cooked to order. Served with cheddar cheese grits and a fresh buttermilk biscuit

$17.99

CINNAMON RASIN PECAN FRENCH TOAST

Pottery House Cafes thick cut cinnamon raisin pecan bread dipped in our seasoned batter. Topped with powdered sugar. Served with butter and syrup

$10.99

CHICKEN AND WAFFLE

Belgian waffles topped with fried chicken tenders, Old Forges praline sauce and chopped pecans

$11.99

SWEET POTATO AND SAUSAGE SKILLET

Sweet potato hash, ground Swaggertys sausage, sauteed onions, Sweet Water Valley Farms cheddar cheese and two eggs cooked to order. Served with a fresh buttermilk biscuit

$12.99

CAFE SAUSAGE AND CHEESE SKILLET

A combination of fried potatoes, ground Swaggertys sausage, sauteed onions, cheddar jack cheese and two eggs cooked to order. Served with a fresh buttermilk biscuit

$11.99

WEEKEND BRUNCH MENU

LUNCH FEATURES AND COMBINATIONS

LUNCH SHRIMP & GRITS

Seasoned shrimp sauteed with celery and bell peppers. Served on Old Mills creamy cheddar cheese grits and topped with crumbled bacon, green onions and parmesan cheese

$13.99

LUNCH FRIED CATFISH

Delta catfish filets hand tossed in our own Old Mills popcorn breading and fried to a golden brown, served with fresh cucumber dill sauce & steak fries

$13.99

LUNCH GRILLED SALMON

Grilled salmon served over a bed of rice with fresh cucumber dill sauce & steamed broccoli

$15.99

LUNCH CHICKEN BREAST

Grilled, natural, cage free chicken breast served over a bed of rice with steamed broccoli. Basted in Old Mills BBQ or teriyaki sauce available upon request

$13.99

POTTERY HOUSE CAFE BROWN

Hot sliced turkey on toasted sourdough bread topped with sliced tomatoes, creamy bacon & cheddar cheese sauce, applewood smoked sliced bacon and parmesan cheese. Served with mashed potatoes

$13.99

LUNCH PRALINE PORK CHOP

A grilled bone-in pork chop topped with warm Old Forges French toast moonshine sauce and chopped pecans. Served with mashed potatoes

$13.99

SOUP & HALF CHICKEN SALAD SANDWICH

Bowl of soup with a half of a chicken salad sandwich

$10.99

GRILLED TRIPLE CHEESE SANDWICH & SOUP

A grilled cheese sandwich made with American, cheddar & provolone cheese on sourdough bread

$11.49

SOUP & / OLD MILLS TRIPLE DECKER CLUB SANDWICH

We are sorry but there are no substitutions on the / Club Sandwich

$11.99

SOUP & PIMENTO CHEESE SANDWICH

Bowl of soup with fresh pimiento cheese served on our bakery fresh toasted olive bread

$12.49

FRIED GREEN TOMATOES

Made with our Old Mills fried green tomato breading & served with our original Old Mills avocado ranch dressing

$10.49

LOADED POTATO CHIPS

House fried crispy potato chips topped with melted cheddar jack cheese, chopped bacon, scallions and sour cream. Served with our avocado ranch dressing for dipping

$11.99

FRIED PICKLES

Spicy dill pickle chips lightly breaded in our green tomato breading, served with our tangy Come Back dipping sauce

$10.99

CHICKEN LIVERS

Lightly breaded, deep fried and topped with caramelized onions. Served with our tangy Come Back dipping sauce

$9.49

BLACK BEAN SPRING ROLLS

Black beans, cheese and seasoning wrapped in an egg roll and deep fried. Served with our original Old Mills chipotle ranch dressing

$11.49

BACON & CHEDDAR DIP

A creamy blend of cheeses including Sweetwater Valley Farms sharp cheddar cheese mixed with applewood smoked bacon and served with fresh fried pork rinds

$11.99

SPINACH ARTICHOKE DIP

A creamy blend of spinach and artichoke hearts served with stone ground corn tortilla chips

$10.99

GRILLED SALMON CAKES

Fresh salmon mixed with cracker crumbs and seasonings. Served with our tangy Come Back sauce and cucumber dill sauce

$10.99

PIMIENTO CHEESE GRIT CAKE

Our stone ground yellow grits mixed with our house made pimiento cheese. Grilled and topped with bourbon glazed pork belly & chowchow

$10.99

STARTERS

THE MILLERS SELECTION

SHRIMP & GRITS

Seasoned shrimp sauteed with celery, onion and bell peppers. Served on Old Mills creamy cheddar cheese grits and topped with bacon, green onions and parmesan cheese

$18.99

CHICKEN GUMBO & GRITS

Chicken breast cooked with tomatoes, okra and creole seasoning served on Old Mills creamy cheddar cheese grits. Served with an Old Mills jalapeno hoe cake

$13.99

FRIED CATFISH FILLETS

Delta catfish hand tossed in our own Old Mills popcorn breading and fried to a golden brown. Served with a fresh cucumber dill sauce, steak fries and coleslaw

$17.49

BREADED CHICKEN TENDERS

Hand breaded with the Old Mills chicken breading, served with honey mustard dressing, coleslaw & steak fries

$15.99

FRIED CHICKEN LIVERS

Hand breaded with the Old Mills chicken breading & topped with grilled onions. Served with our tangy Come Back sauce, coleslaw & mashed potatoes

$13.99

OLD MILLS CHOPPED STEAK

oz. grilled black angus ground beef topped with sauteed mushrooms & onions. Served with mashed potatoes and cinnamon apples

$16.99

OPEN FACED ROAST BEEF

Tender, thinly sliced hot roast beef on sourdough bread, topped with brown gravy. Served with mashed potatoes and cinnamon apples

$13.99

DISTILLERS FETTUCCINE & MEATBALLS

Meatballs made with Dudash Farms ground sausage. Marinated in tomato moonshine sauce and served over fettuccine noodles. Topped with parmesan cheese

$15.99

BEEF SHORT RIBS

Tender, slow cooked, marinated beef short ribs. Served over Old Mills cheddar cheese grits and topped with seasoned carrots

$15.99

GRILLED CHICKEN BREAST

Two grilled, natural cage free chicken breasts served over a bed of rice. Served with steamed broccoli

$17.99

OLE FORGES PECAN FRIED CHICKEN

Two chicken breasts lightly breaded in a pecan breading and fried. Topped with Old Forges French toast moonshine sauce and chopped pecans. Served with a baked sweet potato

$19.99

BUTTERMILK CHICKEN MELT

Two fried chicken breasts topped with sauteed mushrooms and melted Sweetwater Valley Farms buttermilk cheese. Served with steamed broccoli

$19.99

CAFE CHICKEN FLORENTINE

Two grilled chicken breasts topped with sauteed spinach, red onions, grape tomatoes, our creamy spinach artichoke cheese sauce and parmesan

$20.99

CAFE SPECIALS

HEARTY SOUPS

TOMATO BASIL SOUP

$6.49

HOMEMADE CHILI

$6.49

FRENCH ONION SOUP

$6.49

SOUP OF THE DAY

$6.49

LOADED BAKED POTATO SOUP

$6.49

CHICKEN SALAD & FRUIT

Our famous chicken salad served with fresh fruit and a slice of cinnamon raisin pecan bread

$13.99

CHICKEN SALAD & CAFE WEDGE

Our famous chicken salad served with a wedge of iceberg lettuce topped with raspberry walnut vinaigrette, dried cranberries, sliced apples, walnuts and blue cheese crumbles. Served with a slice of cinnamon raisin pecan bread

$14.99

BAKERS GRILLED CHICKEN SALAD

A crisp iceberg blend topped with cheddar jack cheese, tomatoes, bacon bits, mushrooms, broccoli, red onions, and hard boiled egg. Served with fresh baked bread

$16.49

CHICKEN CAESAR SALAD

Fresh romaine lettuce tossed with Caesar dressing, parmesan cheese and topped with Pottery House croutons and grilled chicken breast. Served with fresh baked bread

$16.49

HOUSE SALAD

A crisp iceberg blend topped with carrots, red cabbage, tomatoes, parmesan cheese, red onion and house croutons

$6.99

HOUSE CAESAR SALAD

Fresh romaine lettuce tossed with Caesar dressing, parmesan cheese and topped with house croutons

$6.99

BABY WEDGE

Wedge of iceberg lettuce topped with bacon bits, tomatoes, red onion and blue cheese dressing

$8.99

SOUTHWEST STEAK SALAD

A crisp iceberg blend topped with black bean & corn salsa, red onion, tomatoes, avocado, feta cheese, fried tortilla strips and grilled cajun seasoned sirloin steak. Served with chipotle ranch dressing

$17.99

AUTUMN HARVEST SALAD

A blend of leafy greens, cabbage and carrots topped with dried cranberries, feta cheese, walnuts, maple roasted sweet potatoes and chopped bacon. Served with a sorghum bourbon vinaigrette dressing and cinnamon raisin pecan bread

$13.99

STRAWBERRY SPINACH SALAD

Fresh baby spinach topped with strawberries, mandarin oranges, toasted almonds & blue cheese crumbles. Served with raspberry walnut vinaigrette and cinnamon raisin pecan bread

$14.99

GARDEN FRESH SALADS

POTTERY HOUSE SIGNATURE SANDWICHES

FRIED GREEN TOMATO BLT

Fried green tomatoes breaded with our Old Mills fried green tomato breading, applewood smoked bacon, lettuce & avocado bacon spread. Served on toasted sourdough bread with steak fries

$12.99

OUR ORIGINAL CHICKEN REUBEN

Shaved rotisserie chicken breast, creamy coleslaw, island dressing and melted swiss cheese on grilled onion rye bread served with home made potato chips

$11.99

CAFE GARDEN MELT

Spinach, mushrooms, red peppers, cream cheese & mayo, topped with melted gruyere, swiss & cheddar cheeses on grilled onion rye bread with tomatoes & red onion. Served with steak fries

$11.99

CHICKEN QUESADILLA WRAP

Diced southwest chicken breast, roasted red peppers, caramelized onions & cheddar jack cheese grilled in an herb tortilla. Served with salsa, chipotle ranch and steak fries

$12.99

CLASSIC CHICKEN CLUB

Grilled chicken breast topped with cheddar cheese, applewood smoked bacon, lettuce, tomatoes & red onion. Served on grilled kaiser roll with steak fries

$14.99

RIBEYE STEAK SANDWICH

Grilled Black Angus ribeye served on a hoagie with lettuce, tomato & red onions. Served with steak fries

$21.99

SMOKEHOUSE BURGER

Basted in BBQ sauce, topped with sauteed onions, applewood smoked bacon & cheddar cheese. Served on a grilled corn meal dusted kaiser roll with lettuce & tomato

$15.49

POTTERY MELT BURGER

Topped with sauteed onions and melted Swiss cheese. Served on our bakery fresh, grilled onion rye bread

$14.49

THE SOUTHERN

Topped with a bourbon glaze, pimiento cheese, sauteed onions and applewood smoked bacon. Served on an Old Forges spent grain bun with lettuce & tomato

$16.99

BLACK ANGUS BURGERS

HOMEMADE DESSERTS

COCONUT CREAM PIE

CHOCOLATE PECAN PIE

CARROT CAKE

CHOCOLATE CAKE

KEY LIME PIE

PEANUT BUTTER PIE

HOT CHOCOLATE PIE

LEMONADE PIE

SOURDOUGH

HONEY WHEAT

MULTIGRAIN

CINNAMON RAISIN PECAN

GREEN OLIVE

ONION RYE

SOURDOUGH BREAD BOWL

ARTISAN BREADS

SIDES

STEAK FRIES

$4.49

HOMEMADE POTATO CHIPS

$4.49

MASHED POTATOES

$4.49

PASTA SALAD

$4.49

CINNAMON APPLES

$4.49

STEAMED BROCCOLI

$4.49

COLESLAW

$4.49

CHEDDAR CHEESE GRITS

$4.49

JALAPENO CORN PUDDING

$4.49

FRESH FRUIT CUP

$4.49

BAKED POTATO

$4.49

GARDEN RICE

$4.49

VEGETABLE OF THE DAY

$4.49

BAKED SWEET POTATO

$4.49

HAND CUT BLACK ANGUS, CHOICE RIBEYE

$28.99

FROM THE GRILL